Antennas are really a lot like boats: No
boat will do everything well and no
antenna will either. Boats and antennas
that try to do everything usually fail
across the board.

FWIW, SGC-237, -230, and -231 tuners
need 23 feet only to tune from 1.6 MHz
to 3.3 MHz. Above 3.3 MHz, these SGC
tuners require only eight (8) feet.

The Icom AH-4, for example, needs 23
feet only to tune down to 3.5 MHz, but
will tune from 7 MHz up with Icom's
AH-2b whip (8.2 feet long).

But it doesn't matter what lengths the
tuners require if there is no desire to
operate in that frequency range, and
chances are excellent that recreational
boaters will not be found at the very
low frequencies.

As has been pointed out, some antenna
lengths will be more taxing for an
autotuner than other lengths. Your
objective is not to make life easier for
your tuner, especially when doing so may
move you farther from your real needs.
You may not even need a tuner! Your
objective is to achieve your
communication goals.

You might give some thought to posting
on one of the cruising newsgroups to ask
experienced cruisers for their thoughts
on things like "if you had only one
frequency to operate on, what would it
be? Among other things, that might be
the basis for an antenna you can stow
for emergencies. But tell them where and
how you'll be cruising and what you want
the ssb for (email, emergencies,
boat-to-boat communication, etc.) Then
return to the antenna design questions.

Keep to it!

Chuck