Well do I have egg on my face!

Gary, you are correct, of course, in stating that there is not a lot of
difference between the vertical radiation patterns of half-wave and
quarter-wave antennas. Surely not the differences I was alluding to.

And so my statements to the contrary were just plain wrong.

While I was writing half-wave, I was thinking of something longer, like
3/4 wave. I should have been more careful and I do apologize.

My point, however, is just as valid. Many sailboats sport 45' backstay
antennas and that is close to 3/4 wavelength in the 15 MHz range. A 3/4
wave antenna has maximum vertical radiation at 45 degrees! I would say a
16- or even an 8-foot whip would be very competitive with such a
backstay antenna at the lower radiation angles needed for transoceanic
communication.

At higher marine frequencies, 3/4 wavelength is obviously even less than
45 feet.

Of course, the 3/4 wave will be efficient and easy on the autotuner.

I'll try to keep my brain in synch with my typing, henceforth.

Chuck