"DSK" wrote
There is no category of person who can be "held incommunicado
indefinitely."

Spies, pirates, and mutineers caught in the act can be killed on the
spot, but when captured they must also be given due process.

Ahhh, now I see what you missed. These people did get "due process" in the
form of a militry tribunal back in Afghanistan or Iraq. Thats how they ended
up at Gitmo instead of a local prison, being shot, or being set free.

I we houldn't hold them indefinately. We should have been hanging them from
day one.