BoatBanter.com

BoatBanter.com (https://www.boatbanter.com/)
-   ASA (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/)
-   -   Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx (https://www.boatbanter.com/asa/19232-citizen-yachting-watch-jr4xxx.html)

Chris Brady February 16th 04 07:04 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
Whilst at Antigua Airport in the duty free shop run by a crowd called
'Colombian Emeralds International' I stupidly purchased a Citizen
Eco-Drive chronograph watch specifically for sailing/yachting. That
was what the assistant told me it was for. Unfortunately I did not
have time to fully check out the features. I should have been warned
by the fact that she sold me the display model which might well have
been an old discontinued version. It was dated 2003 on the reverse.

During the flight home to the UK whilst reading the instruction
booklet I was (and still am) puzzled as to what features the watch
actually has for yachting/sailing.

So after returning home I looked on the Internet for the Citizen UK
web site but could not find one. But I did find this site:

http://www.citizendealer.com/citizen...ng_watches.htm

This stated the following details for both versions:

Citizen Model JR4010-51L / Citizen Model JR4000-55L

* Sailhawk Eco-Drive Yacht Timer Combination Quartz Watch --- The
Stars and Stripes America's Cup 2003 Official Watch. Features time and
calendar in 22 time zones, 1/100 second chronograph that measures up
to 24 hours, 99 minute countdown timer, one touch interchangeable
analog/digital times, retractable hands for display visibility, and
rotating 360 degree bezel.

* The official America's Cup insignia appears on the watch caseback
(big deal and hardly a selling point)
* Metal bracelet with all titanium case (that can be easily scratched
trying to take some links out).
* Blue dial (wow!!)
* Water resistant to 100 meters (useful)
* Safety fold over clasp with push button (useful?)
* 4 year power reserve (saves on batteries I suppose)

No other features are listed!!

So unfortunately apart from having a non-functional logo marked 'Stars
and Stripes' or 'America's Cup' I can see no extra features for
yachting that these two watches provide over and above what my very
considerably cheaper Casio basic sports timer watch already has (that
is apart from the Eco-Drive feature).

Whilst the waterproof feature is always useful for yachting, where are
the other features necessary for yachting/sailing?

I am now thinking that the watch I have is actually a simple timer and
not for yachting at all.

Specifically I'm referring to the complete lack of any navigation
functions including direction estimation, tacking angles, ability to
read in the dark (e.g. a back-lit display which my Casio has) -
important for night sailing, and wind direction and strength
estimation - to name a few.

Certainly there are absolutely NO instructions in the accompanying
booklet to describe the yachting functions (if they exist at all), not
even how to use the rotating bezel.

So please - what is the difference between the JR4000-55L and the
JR4010-51L models. Both seem to have the same features. So how do I
tell which version of the watch I have?

Also I am also having GREAT difficulty in removing some strap links to
allow me to actually wear the watch. The small arrows on some links do
not indicate any way of removing them, there are no instructions in
the booklet, and the small connecting pins are impossible to push
through using a small screwdriver. Indeed I have scratched the surface
of some of the links trying to do this. This does not say much about
the supposed hardness of the titanium band - but then I notice that
this is made in China so I suppose it is really made of soft metal and
not titanium after all.

The other SERIOUS issue I have with the watch is the button marked C
in the booklet. This is very easy to inadvertantly press with my
jacket sleeve and doing so appears to move the hour hand to indicate
the incorrect time. This is not a fault I would expect for a watch
that cost me over £200.

Frankly my year's old Casio Sports Timer cost £15 and is far better
suited to yachting and sailing. To say that I feel ripped off is an
understatement. I will NEVER purchase a Citizen watch again, and
certainly not from any duty free shop (so-called) with the word
'Colombian' in the title.

Citizen have deigned to reply to my emailed enquiries for further
information.

Fair winds and calm seas - but not for racing

C.J.Brady

SAIL LOCO February 16th 04 07:30 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
These watches usually sell for around $150 on ebay. Hope you didn't pay more
than that.
S/V Express 30 "Ringmaster"
"No shirt, no skirt, full service"

James Lothian February 16th 04 09:56 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
Chris Brady wrote:

Whilst at Antigua Airport in the duty free shop run by a crowd called
'Colombian Emeralds International' I stupidly purchased a Citizen
Eco-Drive chronograph watch specifically for sailing/yachting. That
was what the assistant told me it was for. Unfortunately I did not
have time to fully check out the features. I should have been warned
by the fact that she sold me the display model which might well have
been an old discontinued version. It was dated 2003 on the reverse.

During the flight home to the UK whilst reading the instruction
booklet I was (and still am) puzzled as to what features the watch
actually has for yachting/sailing.

So after returning home I looked on the Internet for the Citizen UK
web site but could not find one. But I did find this site:

http://www.citizendealer.com/citizen...ng_watches.htm

This stated the following details for both versions:

Citizen Model JR4010-51L / Citizen Model JR4000-55L

* Sailhawk Eco-Drive Yacht Timer Combination Quartz Watch --- The
Stars and Stripes America's Cup 2003 Official Watch. Features time and
calendar in 22 time zones, 1/100 second chronograph that measures up
to 24 hours, 99 minute countdown timer, one touch interchangeable
analog/digital times, retractable hands for display visibility, and
rotating 360 degree bezel.

* The official America's Cup insignia appears on the watch caseback
(big deal and hardly a selling point)
* Metal bracelet with all titanium case (that can be easily scratched
trying to take some links out).
* Blue dial (wow!!)
* Water resistant to 100 meters (useful)
* Safety fold over clasp with push button (useful?)
* 4 year power reserve (saves on batteries I suppose)

No other features are listed!!


Except for:
Sailhawk Eco-Drive Yacht Timer
Combination Quartz Watch---
The Stars and Stripes America's
Cup 2003 Official Watch.
Features time and calendar in
22 time zones, 1/100 second
chronograph that measures up
to 24 hours, 99 minute
countdown timer, one touch
interchangeable analog/digital
times, retractable hands for
display visibility, and rotating
360 degree bezel.

So unfortunately apart from having a non-functional logo marked 'Stars
and Stripes' or 'America's Cup' I can see no extra features for
yachting that these two watches provide over and above what my very
considerably cheaper Casio basic sports timer watch already has (that
is apart from the Eco-Drive feature).

Whilst the waterproof feature is always useful for yachting, where are
the other features necessary for yachting/sailing?

I am now thinking that the watch I have is actually a simple timer and
not for yachting at all.

Specifically I'm referring to the complete lack of any navigation
functions including direction estimation, tacking angles, ability to
read in the dark (e.g. a back-lit display which my Casio has) -
important for night sailing, and wind direction and strength
estimation - to name a few.

Certainly there are absolutely NO instructions in the accompanying
booklet to describe the yachting functions (if they exist at all), not
even how to use the rotating bezel.

So please - what is the difference between the JR4000-55L and the
JR4010-51L models. Both seem to have the same features. So how do I
tell which version of the watch I have?


One is titanium, the other is steel. This is described clearly on the
URL you posted.

Also I am also having GREAT difficulty in removing some strap links to
allow me to actually wear the watch. The small arrows on some links do
not indicate any way of removing them, there are no instructions in
the booklet, and the small connecting pins are impossible to push
through using a small screwdriver.


It's much easier if you use a suitable tool. Small cheap tools are
available
for about £5, e.g. from clockspares.net. Or take it to a jewellers.

Indeed I have scratched the surface
of some of the links trying to do this. This does not say much about
the supposed hardness of the titanium band - but then I notice that
this is made in China so I suppose it is really made of soft metal and
not titanium after all.


If it says it's titanium, it's titanium. Titanium scratches easily.

The other SERIOUS issue I have with the watch is the button marked C
in the booklet. This is very easy to inadvertantly press with my
jacket sleeve and doing so appears to move the hour hand to indicate
the incorrect time. This is not a fault I would expect for a watch
that cost me over £200.


I don't have a sailhawk, but AFAIK button C moves the hands away from
the digital displays to let you see them clearly (I wish my Skyhawk had
this feature). There's a good chance that this is mentioned in the
instructions (the manual for the Skyhawk is essential reading).

Frankly my year's old Casio Sports Timer cost £15 and is far better
suited to yachting and sailing. To say that I feel ripped off is an
understatement. I will NEVER purchase a Citizen watch again, and
certainly not from any duty free shop (so-called) with the word
'Colombian' in the title.


I would be very happy to relieve you of your burden, and would pay you
£15,
so that you can buy another Casio.

Citizen have deigned to reply to my emailed enquiries for further
information.


Good for them.

James

John Rowland February 17th 04 12:12 AM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
"Chris Brady" wrote in message
om...

I stupidly purchased a Citizen Eco-Drive
chronograph watch specifically for sailing/yachting.


"Yachting watches" do not generally have wind direction or the other complex
functions you list. They are usually perfectly simple watches with one extra
featu a coloured spot which changes colour every 15 seconds. This is
generally achieved by a hole, or several holes, in the dial revealing a
4-coloured disc beneath which rotates at the same speed as the second hand.
If you know why a yachtsman would want that, you know more than me. I'm
afraid your Citizen Yachting watch doesn't seem to be a yachting watch in
anything but name.

--
John Rowland - Spamtrapped
Transport Plans for the London Area, updated 2001
http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Acro...69/tpftla.html
A man's vehicle is a symbol of his manhood.
That's why my vehicle's the Piccadilly Line -
It's the size of a county and it comes every two and a half minutes



Olaf Peuss February 17th 04 12:13 AM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
Chris Brady wrote:

Whilst at Antigua Airport in the duty free shop run by a crowd called
'Colombian Emeralds International' I stupidly purchased a Citizen
Eco-Drive chronograph watch specifically for sailing/yachting. That
was what the assistant told me it was for. Unfortunately I did not
have time to fully check out the features.


Why on earth did you purchase a watch in rather a hurry? Frankly
speaking, you bought something of which you still don't know whether you
need it - chances are that you'll never need it. Your whole case sounds
like a typical "buyer's remorse whining," so little wonder that people
might feel tempted to add insult to injury.


I should have been warned
by the fact that she sold me the display model which might well have
been an old discontinued version. It was dated 2003 on the reverse.

During the flight home to the UK whilst reading the instruction
booklet I was (and still am) puzzled as to what features the watch
actually has for yachting/sailing.


Why didn't you ask the shop assistant to answer those questions, i.e.,
BEFORE you put money (or your credit card) on the counter?


So after returning home I looked on the Internet for the Citizen UK
web site but could not find one. But I did find this site:

http://www.citizendealer.com/citizen...ng_watches.htm

This stated the following details for both versions:

Citizen Model JR4010-51L / Citizen Model JR4000-55L

* Sailhawk Eco-Drive Yacht Timer Combination Quartz Watch --- The
Stars and Stripes America's Cup 2003 Official Watch. Features time and
calendar in 22 time zones, 1/100 second chronograph that measures up
to 24 hours, 99 minute countdown timer, one touch interchangeable
analog/digital times, retractable hands for display visibility, and
rotating 360 degree bezel.

* The official America's Cup insignia appears on the watch caseback
(big deal and hardly a selling point)
* Metal bracelet with all titanium case (that can be easily scratched
trying to take some links out).


...., particularly when using inappropriate tools for that. Any
watchmaker with half a brain can take links out without scratching or
denting anything in a matter of seconds - just a question of deploying
the right tools.


* Blue dial (wow!!)
* Water resistant to 100 meters (useful)
* Safety fold over clasp with push button (useful?)
* 4 year power reserve (saves on batteries I suppose)

No other features are listed!!


So, what exactly would you want from a watch? I just want mine to tell
me the time (and date). :-) And mine has only one additional time zone,
not 22!


So unfortunately apart from having a non-functional logo marked 'Stars
and Stripes' or 'America's Cup' I can see no extra features for
yachting that these two watches provide over and above what my very
considerably cheaper Casio basic sports timer watch already has (that
is apart from the Eco-Drive feature).

Whilst the waterproof feature is always useful for yachting, where are
the other features necessary for yachting/sailing?


Again: what exactly would you want? GPS? Radio control? SOS signal
transmitter?


I am now thinking that the watch I have is actually a simple timer and
not for yachting at all.


So, why did you buy that Citizen without making yourself familiar with
its idiosyncracies?


Specifically I'm referring to the complete lack of any navigation
functions including direction estimation, tacking angles, ability to
read in the dark (e.g. a back-lit display which my Casio has) -
important for night sailing, and wind direction and strength
estimation - to name a few.


You've failed to list the most important feature of them all: the yacht
itself! :-
I know it sounds sarcastic but IMO you've been blinded by some
advertising slogans and spontaneously decided to spend a lot of money on
a watch because you were afraid of missing the bargain of your life. :-


Certainly there are absolutely NO instructions in the accompanying
booklet to describe the yachting functions (if they exist at all), not
even how to use the rotating bezel.


Excuse me but operating a *rotatable* bezel should be pretty much
self-explanatory. (I hope it isn't rotating, otherwise you might hurt
yourself with it it whilst wearing the watch. :-)
It's the same with the Breitling Navitimer watch: If you're unfamiliar
with the principles of aviation and navigation, the built-in slide rule
is practically useless to you.
All functions should be described in the instruction booklet, but they
won't explain what to use the functions for. Either you know yourself
what to do with all the functions or they won't be of any value to you.


So please - what is the difference between the JR4000-55L and the
JR4010-51L models. Both seem to have the same features. So how do I
tell which version of the watch I have?


Funny, really: You refer to a website where the differences between the
two watch models are clearly stated: The JR4010-51L features titanium
whereas the JR4000-55L features stainless steel. You wrote above that
you bought a watch with a titanium bracelet, so work out yourself which
model you've got.


Also I am also having GREAT difficulty in removing some strap links to
allow me to actually wear the watch. The small arrows on some links do
not indicate any way of removing them, there are no instructions in
the booklet, and the small connecting pins are impossible to push
through using a small screwdriver. Indeed I have scratched the surface
of some of the links trying to do this. This does not say much about
the supposed hardness of the titanium band - but then I notice that
this is made in China so I suppose it is really made of soft metal and
not titanium after all.


Firstly, it just means that you are ignorant about metal as otherwise
you would know that titanium scratches quite easily. Secondly, it means
that you are ignorant about watchmaking and the tools required for that
because you've tried to take links out of the bracelet using a
screwdriver. And finally, it means that you are too tightfisted to spend
a few quid for a watchmaker to have the bracelet made fit, because you
rather scratch a watch that retails for $500!


The other SERIOUS issue I have with the watch is the button marked C
in the booklet. This is very easy to inadvertantly press with my
jacket sleeve and doing so appears to move the hour hand to indicate
the incorrect time. This is not a fault I would expect for a watch
that cost me over £200.


Maybe you should see your tailor about that. :-)


Frankly my year's old Casio Sports Timer cost £15 and is far better
suited to yachting and sailing. To say that I feel ripped off is an
understatement. I will NEVER purchase a Citizen watch again, and
certainly not from any duty free shop (so-called) with the word
'Colombian' in the title.


There's only one person to blame in this affair. Needless to say who
that person is, you'll have figured it out by now.


Citizen have deigned to reply to my emailed enquiries for further
information.


And? What did they say? Or did you want to say that they have NOT EVEN
deigned to reply?


Kind regards,
Olaf

--
E-Mail only to reply-to address, please.

Tee February 17th 04 12:53 AM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
On 16 Feb 2004 11:04:37 -0800, (Chris
Brady) wrote:

Whilst at Antigua Airport in the duty free shop run by a crowd called
'Colombian Emeralds International' I stupidly purchased a Citizen


Why are you whining in every GD usenet group you can find?
Excessive cross posting is Usnet abuse and deserves a PLONK
so here it is:

PLONK

Donal February 17th 04 01:01 AM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 

"Olaf Peuss" wrote in message
...
Chris Brady wrote:

Whilst at Antigua Airport in the duty free shop run by a crowd called
'Colombian Emeralds International' I stupidly purchased a Citizen
Eco-Drive chronograph watch specifically for sailing/yachting. That
was what the assistant told me it was for. Unfortunately I did not
have time to fully check out the features.


Why on earth did you purchase a watch in rather a hurry? Frankly
speaking, you bought something of which you still don't know whether you
need it - chances are that you'll never need it. Your whole case sounds
like a typical "buyer's remorse whining," so little wonder that people
might feel tempted to add insult to injury.


It seems to me that you need to bolster your ego by attacking strangers on
the Internet.

An undersized penis is a much bigger(smaller??) problem than a dodgy watch.


The real lesson in this, is that Duty Free shops can only offer bargains on
items that attract a large amount of tax. I don't believe that watches are
usually taxed heavily. Therefore, airport shops won't be cheaper than high
street outlets.


Cigarettes and booze are taxed heavily in the UK, and therefore they are
much cheaper when they can be purchased "Duty Free".


Most other things that are sold in airport shops are more expensive than in
the high street.


Regards


Donal

--




Regards



Donal
--





Olaf Peuss February 17th 04 07:02 AM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
Donal wrote:

It seems to me that you need to bolster your ego by attacking strangers on
the Internet.

An undersized penis is a much bigger(smaller??) problem than a dodgy watch.


I love amateur psychologists like you - with the emphasis being on
AMATEUR... ;-)


The real lesson in this, is that Duty Free shops can only offer bargains on
items that attract a large amount of tax. I don't believe that watches are
usually taxed heavily. Therefore, airport shops won't be cheaper than high
street outlets.
Cigarettes and booze are taxed heavily in the UK, and therefore they are
much cheaper when they can be purchased "Duty Free".
Most other things that are sold in airport shops are more expensive than in
the high street.


You aren't exactly telling me anything new. You'll have to admit,
however, that there's a "little" difference between buying some packs of
cigarettes (and/or a bottle of whisky) and purchasing a high tech watch.


Kind regards,
Olaf

--
E-Mail only to reply-to address, please.

Kent Betts February 17th 04 10:52 AM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 

"Chris Brady"
Citizen have deigned to reply to my emailed enquiries for further
information.


Have they? What was their response?



Hugo 'NOx' Tyson February 17th 04 04:52 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 

(Chris Brady) writes:

* Sailhawk Eco-Drive Yacht Timer Combination Quartz Watch --- The
Stars and Stripes America's Cup 2003 Official Watch. Features time and
calendar in 22 time zones,


1/100 second chronograph that measures up to 24 hours,


That's a yachting (racing) feature.

99 minute countdown timer


That's also a yachting (racing) feature.

....I can see no extra features for yachting that these two watches
provide over and above what my very considerably cheaper Casio basic
sports timer watch already has (that is apart from the Eco-Drive
feature).

Whilst the waterproof feature is always useful for yachting, where are
the other features necessary for yachting/sailing?


Like what? Name some? It's *watch*, not a GPS, nor a compass, nor a
barometer, nor a sextant.

Specifically I'm referring to the complete lack of any navigation
functions including direction estimation, tacking angles, ability to
read in the dark (e.g. a back-lit display which my Casio has) -
important for night sailing, and wind direction and strength
estimation - to name a few.


How would a watch do these things? (except read in the dark - are you sure
it's not luminous?) You may as well say "it doesn't do any sailing
functions such as reefing, tacking, trimming and sheeting - and it can't
even be used as an anchor!" ;-)

Certainly there are absolutely NO instructions in the accompanying
booklet to describe the yachting functions (if they exist at all), not
even how to use the rotating bezel.


If you can't work out how to use a rotating bezel on your own, no amount of
help from here or from a manual will be able to teach you.

The other SERIOUS issue I have with the watch is the button marked C
in the booklet. This is very easy to inadvertantly press with my
jacket sleeve and doing so appears to move the hour hand to indicate
the incorrect time. This is not a fault I would expect for a watch
that cost me over £200.


Is this the feature "retractable hands for display visibility" that you
mentioned above? If you press C again does it go back to "correct" time?

Citizen have deigned to reply to my emailed enquiries for further
information.


Did you mean "not deigned" ? Are you American? ;-)

- Huge

Donal February 17th 04 06:59 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 

"Olaf Peuss" wrote in message
...
Donal wrote:

It seems to me that you need to bolster your ego by attacking strangers

on
the Internet.

An undersized penis is a much bigger(smaller??) problem than a dodgy

watch.

I love amateur psychologists like you - with the emphasis being on
AMATEUR... ;-)


Fair comment!



Cigarettes and booze are taxed heavily in the UK, and therefore they are
much cheaper when they can be purchased "Duty Free".
Most other things that are sold in airport shops are more expensive than

in
the high street.


You aren't exactly telling me anything new. You'll have to admit,
however, that there's a "little" difference between buying some packs of
cigarettes (and/or a bottle of whisky) and purchasing a high tech watch.


I agree. However, I am surprised at the amount of flaming in this thread.
Anybody would be very relaxed after a couple of weeks in a Carribbean
resort. I'd say that there are loads of people in Chris's position.

Regards


Donal
--





Eric Jorgensen February 17th 04 07:26 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
On 17 Feb 2004 16:52:51 +0000
Hugo 'NOx' Tyson wrote:


(Chris Brady) writes:

Whilst the waterproof feature is always useful for yachting, where
are the other features necessary for yachting/sailing?


Like what? Name some? It's *watch*, not a GPS, nor a compass, nor a
barometer, nor a sextant.

Specifically I'm referring to the complete lack of any navigation
functions including direction estimation, tacking angles, ability to
read in the dark (e.g. a back-lit display which my Casio has) -
important for night sailing, and wind direction and strength
estimation - to name a few.


How would a watch do these things? (except read in the dark - are you
sure it's not luminous?) You may as well say "it doesn't do any
sailing functions such as reefing, tacking, trimming and sheeting -
and it can't even be used as an anchor!" ;-)



Well, a digital compass isn't hard to implement, nor is an inertial
sensor. The parts required for those are cheaply available and quite
tiny. But i have no idea how useful those would be to a sailor. At least
when strapped to one's wrist.

Maybe he wants a watch that does everything but tell dirty jokes?
Maybe he wants a watch that tells dirty jokes?

I agree that it sounds like buyer's remorse. hasty purchases can do
that. I feel for anyone who goes through that, but, sheesh, if you can't
take it back, sell it on eBay.


Richard Faulkner February 17th 04 10:07 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 

Try www.suunto.com and look at the sailing gizmo with a built in GPS. It
seems to do what you want for about £500.

They also do a golf one.

--
Richard Faulkner

Donal February 17th 04 10:52 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 

OzOne wrote in message ...
On Tue, 17 Feb 2004 01:01:02 -0000, "Donal"
scribbled thusly:


Donal, the watch is not "dodgy"
It is featured and performs exactly as advertised.
The fool bought a watch that didn't have the bells and whistles that
he expected on a "sailing watch"
He didn't do the research, bought the wrong watch and is now trying to
fob the blame for his stupidity onto the company via every bloody
newsgoup in the world.


He was *sold* a watch. The sales assistant led him to believe that he was
buying a "yachting" watch. It appears that the watch has very few sailing
features, if any. He was conned.


Regards


Donal
--




omniscient idiot February 17th 04 11:38 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
"Donal" wrote in message

snipped

I agree. However, I am surprised at the amount of flaming in this thread.
Anybody would be very relaxed after a couple of weeks in a Carribbean
resort. I'd say that there are loads of people in Chris's position.


Fair point. Though I am not one of the wiser men of the internet.... I
would say some criticism toward Mr. Brady is necessary. After all, I
suspect a good number of people (myself included) routinely read the
newsgroups to determine whether this thing is a good idea, what would
be the best etc. in this case, this is almost an unofficial consumer
review of the Citizen thingy. In other words, if you somehow review
something to be read by many people, do it well.

That said, I hope Mr. Brady does not become markedly withdrawn or
angry at this world due to this thread (sorry, folks ... I do not
intend to heap even more insult to insult to injury) - I hope we will
learn how to say things without excessive flame, as you apparently do
(though it is an art I haven't mastered myself). But again, this is a
newsgroup - and an alt. one at that. Regards, oi

Donal February 17th 04 11:57 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 

OzOne wrote in message ...
On Tue, 17 Feb 2004 22:52:49 -0000, "Donal"
scribbled thusly:


OzOne wrote in message

...
On Tue, 17 Feb 2004 01:01:02 -0000, "Donal"
scribbled thusly:


Donal, the watch is not "dodgy"
It is featured and performs exactly as advertised.
The fool bought a watch that didn't have the bells and whistles that
he expected on a "sailing watch"
He didn't do the research, bought the wrong watch and is now trying to
fob the blame for his stupidity onto the company via every bloody
newsgoup in the world.


He was *sold* a watch. The sales assistant led him to believe that he

was
buying a "yachting" watch. It appears that the watch has very few

sailing
features, if any. He was conned.



He bought a watch that's waterproof, has a timer/countdown timer,
rotating bezel and a number of other features.
What more could you want?

Tell me Donal, do you regard a sailing watch as one with an unreliable
windspeed meter and extremely basic GPS as an essential sailing watch
or a gimick laden piece of crap?


My sailing watch tells the time, and is waterproof. It didn't cost much

I've got a countdown timer on one of the boat instruments.

However, that doesn't mean that I would feel superior to someone who got
conned.


We've all been conned at some point in our lives. It's commonly known as
"experience". Being experienced doesn't make you any brighter than anybody
else, ... it just means that you have been conned more often!




Regards



Donal
--









Dennis Pogson February 18th 04 09:07 AM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 


--
Remove "nospam" from return address.
"Richard Faulkner" wrote in message
...

Try www.suunto.com and look at the sailing gizmo with a built in GPS. It
seems to do what you want for about £500.

They also do a golf one.

--
Richard Faulkner


You wouldn't be able to hit the ball very far with a watch, and what would
you use for those delicate chip shots around the green? I much prefer a full
set of Wilsons or Callaways.



Olaf Peuss February 18th 04 03:36 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
omniscient idiot wrote:

[flaming in this thread]
Anybody would be very relaxed after a couple of weeks in a Carribbean
resort. I'd say that there are loads of people in Chris's position.


Fair point. Though I am not one of the wiser men of the internet.... I
would say some criticism toward Mr. Brady is necessary. After all, I
suspect a good number of people (myself included) routinely read the
newsgroups to determine whether this thing is a good idea, what would
be the best etc. in this case, this is almost an unofficial consumer
review of the Citizen thingy. In other words, if you somehow review
something to be read by many people, do it well.


My sentiments exactly. Before one starts criticising a product or
service, the critic should consider whether all points have been
reviewed fairly and that it isn't just a flame on the item being
subjected to a "critique" (or rather, in that case, criticism).
Unfortunately, Chris Brady seems to be good at criticising but his
ability of accepting his own mistakes - and he made quite a few of them
- doesn't seem to be at eye level with his capability of criticising. :-(


That said, I hope Mr. Brady does not become markedly withdrawn or
angry at this world due to this thread (sorry, folks ... I do not
intend to heap even more insult to insult to injury) - I hope we will
learn how to say things without excessive flame, as you apparently do
(though it is an art I haven't mastered myself). But again, this is a
newsgroup - and an alt. one at that. Regards, oi


I'm certainly far from being the most tactful person in the world. In
fact, I usually take a quite direct approach. However, I don't think
that I've ever called anyone names or verbally abused anyone. It's all
very well within "the Usenet standards" and although there's always room
for improvement, I don't think that I've been overly condescending with
our poor Chris Brady. It's also worth noting that he hasn't replied to
anyone in this group although he has received quite a lot of feedback -
probably because it hasn't been the feedback that he hoped for when he
posted his article - goes to prove my point that he isn't good at
accepting the fact that he alone is responsible for the mistakes in that
Citizen watch purchase.
Hope he hasn't thrown himself in front of a train, at least not without
bequeathing said Citizen watch to a charity organisation. ;-)

Kind regards,
Olaf

--
E-Mail only to reply-to address, please.

Richard Faulkner February 18th 04 10:26 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
Looked like a troll to me.

If it was, it got the desired response.

Regds

In message , Olaf Peuss writes
omniscient idiot wrote:

[flaming in this thread]
Anybody would be very relaxed after a couple of weeks in a Carribbean
resort. I'd say that there are loads of people in Chris's position.

Fair point. Though I am not one of the wiser men of the internet....

would say some criticism toward Mr. Brady is necessary. After all, I
suspect a good number of people (myself included) routinely read the
newsgroups to determine whether this thing is a good idea, what would
be the best etc. in this case, this is almost an unofficial consumer
review of the Citizen thingy. In other words, if you somehow review
something to be read by many people, do it well.


My sentiments exactly. Before one starts criticising a product or
service, the critic should consider whether all points have been
reviewed fairly and that it isn't just a flame on the item being
subjected to a "critique" (or rather, in that case, criticism).
Unfortunately, Chris Brady seems to be good at criticising but his
ability of accepting his own mistakes - and he made quite a few of them
- doesn't seem to be at eye level with his capability of criticising. :-(


That said, I hope Mr. Brady does not become markedly withdrawn or
angry at this world due to this thread (sorry, folks ... I do not
intend to heap even more insult to insult to injury) - I hope we will
learn how to say things without excessive flame, as you apparently do
(though it is an art I haven't mastered myself). But again, this is a
newsgroup - and an alt. one at that. Regards, oi


I'm certainly far from being the most tactful person in the world. In
fact, I usually take a quite direct approach. However, I don't think
that I've ever called anyone names or verbally abused anyone. It's all
very well within "the Usenet standards" and although there's always
room for improvement, I don't think that I've been overly condescending
with our poor Chris Brady. It's also worth noting that he hasn't
replied to anyone in this group although he has received quite a lot of
feedback - probably because it hasn't been the feedback that he hoped
for when he posted his article - goes to prove my point that he isn't
good at accepting the fact that he alone is responsible for the
mistakes in that Citizen watch purchase.
Hope he hasn't thrown himself in front of a train, at least not without
bequeathing said Citizen watch to a charity organisation. ;-)

Kind regards,
Olaf


--
Richard Faulkner

n February 19th 04 01:41 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
I also purchased a citizen watch from Columbian Emeralds International in St
Lucia. They couldnt have been more helpful and were very knowledgable about
the watch. The cost was $260, which at the current x-rate is about £140. For
this you get a very good timepiece, a great sailing watch (IF you read the
instructions) and a nice looking piece of arm jewellery.

There are more features on this watch than you can shake a stick at and all
are aimed at sailing. It has 2 alarms, multiple time zones (which I have
used crossing the atlantic) including UTC! a race timer with many countdown
functions, chronograph, calendar and timer.

I am happy with my purchase because I went in with my eyes wide open and
knew what I wanted, what I cannot understand is why Chris hasnt read the
manual?

N


"Chris Brady" wrote in message
om...
Whilst at Antigua Airport in the duty free shop run by a crowd called
'Colombian Emeralds International' I stupidly purchased a Citizen
Eco-Drive chronograph watch specifically for sailing/yachting. That
was what the assistant told me it was for. Unfortunately I did not
have time to fully check out the features. I should have been warned
by the fact that she sold me the display model which might well have
been an old discontinued version. It was dated 2003 on the reverse.

During the flight home to the UK whilst reading the instruction
booklet I was (and still am) puzzled as to what features the watch
actually has for yachting/sailing.

So after returning home I looked on the Internet for the Citizen UK
web site but could not find one. But I did find this site:

http://www.citizendealer.com/citizen...ng_watches.htm

This stated the following details for both versions:

Citizen Model JR4010-51L / Citizen Model JR4000-55L

* Sailhawk Eco-Drive Yacht Timer Combination Quartz Watch --- The
Stars and Stripes America's Cup 2003 Official Watch. Features time and
calendar in 22 time zones, 1/100 second chronograph that measures up
to 24 hours, 99 minute countdown timer, one touch interchangeable
analog/digital times, retractable hands for display visibility, and
rotating 360 degree bezel.

* The official America's Cup insignia appears on the watch caseback
(big deal and hardly a selling point)
* Metal bracelet with all titanium case (that can be easily scratched
trying to take some links out).
* Blue dial (wow!!)
* Water resistant to 100 meters (useful)
* Safety fold over clasp with push button (useful?)
* 4 year power reserve (saves on batteries I suppose)

No other features are listed!!

So unfortunately apart from having a non-functional logo marked 'Stars
and Stripes' or 'America's Cup' I can see no extra features for
yachting that these two watches provide over and above what my very
considerably cheaper Casio basic sports timer watch already has (that
is apart from the Eco-Drive feature).

Whilst the waterproof feature is always useful for yachting, where are
the other features necessary for yachting/sailing?

I am now thinking that the watch I have is actually a simple timer and
not for yachting at all.

Specifically I'm referring to the complete lack of any navigation
functions including direction estimation, tacking angles, ability to
read in the dark (e.g. a back-lit display which my Casio has) -
important for night sailing, and wind direction and strength
estimation - to name a few.

Certainly there are absolutely NO instructions in the accompanying
booklet to describe the yachting functions (if they exist at all), not
even how to use the rotating bezel.

So please - what is the difference between the JR4000-55L and the
JR4010-51L models. Both seem to have the same features. So how do I
tell which version of the watch I have?

Also I am also having GREAT difficulty in removing some strap links to
allow me to actually wear the watch. The small arrows on some links do
not indicate any way of removing them, there are no instructions in
the booklet, and the small connecting pins are impossible to push
through using a small screwdriver. Indeed I have scratched the surface
of some of the links trying to do this. This does not say much about
the supposed hardness of the titanium band - but then I notice that
this is made in China so I suppose it is really made of soft metal and
not titanium after all.

The other SERIOUS issue I have with the watch is the button marked C
in the booklet. This is very easy to inadvertantly press with my
jacket sleeve and doing so appears to move the hour hand to indicate
the incorrect time. This is not a fault I would expect for a watch
that cost me over £200.

Frankly my year's old Casio Sports Timer cost £15 and is far better
suited to yachting and sailing. To say that I feel ripped off is an
understatement. I will NEVER purchase a Citizen watch again, and
certainly not from any duty free shop (so-called) with the word
'Colombian' in the title.

Citizen have deigned to reply to my emailed enquiries for further
information.

Fair winds and calm seas - but not for racing

C.J.Brady




Olaf Peuss February 19th 04 02:54 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
n wrote:

I also purchased a citizen watch from Columbian Emeralds International in St
Lucia. They couldnt have been more helpful and were very knowledgable about
the watch. The cost was $260, which at the current x-rate is about £140. For
this you get a very good timepiece, a great sailing watch (IF you read the
instructions) and a nice looking piece of arm jewellery.

There are more features on this watch than you can shake a stick at and all
are aimed at sailing. It has 2 alarms, multiple time zones (which I have
used crossing the atlantic) including UTC! a race timer with many countdown
functions, chronograph, calendar and timer.

I am happy with my purchase because I went in with my eyes wide open and
knew what I wanted, what I cannot understand is why Chris hasnt read the
manual?


Ah, finally somebody who has hands-on experience with both the shop and
the watch mentioned in the original article.
Your comment sounds rather different from what Chris Brady had to say.
Obviously you're somebody who
a) knows what he wants and
b) is able to read and comprehend instruction manuals.

Having said that, my personal experience with Citizen wasn't that good.
I bought a Citizen analogue quartz watch about 20 years ago and had
mechanical problems with it: the bracelet broke into two and finally the
crown came off - after only 3 years on my wrist. :-( As a time keeper it
was quite precise though, it never gained more than 5-6 seconds / month
when I wore it 24 / 7.
I bought another Citizen analogue/digital watch about 12 years ago and
experienced the same problems: a malconstructed bracelet and a crown
that came off two days after I had picked up the watch from a battery
change (no, it was a good watchmaker's, not some backyard idiot who
changed batteries by removing the back with a crowbar).

Finally I switched to Tissot and, more recently, to Omega and I'm more
than happy with both brands. Although the watch bug has bitten me again
and I'm seriously considering to buy yet another watch. It could be a
Mido OceanStar or a Marcello C. Nettuno 3 or Tridente GMT - if I feel
like purchasing a watch that falls into the "beater" category - or a IWC
Spitfire UTC if I feel that I urgently need to add a really classy watch
to my collection. :-)

Kind regards,
Olaf

--
E-Mail only to reply-to address, please.

Ferg February 20th 04 10:32 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 

The real lesson in this, is that Duty Free shops can only offer bargains

on
items that attract a large amount of tax.

Cigarettes and booze are taxed heavily in the UK, and therefore they are
much cheaper when they can be purchased "Duty Free".



Kinda like how a nice bottle of rum is cheaper than a 6-pack of beer in
Nassau.

john.



Donal February 21st 04 12:30 AM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 

"Ferg" wrote in message
m...

The real lesson in this, is that Duty Free shops can only offer bargains

on
items that attract a large amount of tax.

Cigarettes and booze are taxed heavily in the UK, and therefore they are
much cheaper when they can be purchased "Duty Free".



Kinda like how a nice bottle of rum is cheaper than a 6-pack of beer in
Nassau.


Ahhh! Memories!!


Two banana daquiris for lunch, every day. Cheapest, and most nourishing
lunch that money could buy.


Regards


Donal
--




david c. February 23rd 04 12:04 PM

Citizen Yachting Watch - JR4xxx
 
"n" wrote in message ...
I also purchased a citizen watch from Columbian Emeralds International in St
Lucia. They couldnt have been more helpful and were very knowledgable about
the watch. The cost was $260, which at the current x-rate is about £140. For
this you get a very good timepiece, a great sailing watch (IF you read the
instructions) and a nice looking piece of arm jewellery.

There are more features on this watch than you can shake a stick at and all
are aimed at sailing. It has 2 alarms, multiple time zones (which I have
used crossing the atlantic) including UTC! a race timer with many countdown
functions, chronograph, calendar and timer.

I am happy with my purchase because I went in with my eyes wide open and
knew what I wanted, what I cannot understand is why Chris hasnt read the
manual?

N


"Chris Brady" wrote in message
om...
Whilst at Antigua Airport in the duty free shop run by a crowd called
'Colombian Emeralds International' I stupidly purchased a Citizen
Eco-Drive chronograph watch specifically for sailing/yachting. That
was what the assistant told me it was for. Unfortunately I did not
have time to fully check out the features. I should have been warned
by the fact that she sold me the display model which might well have
been an old discontinued version. It was dated 2003 on the reverse.

During the flight home to the UK whilst reading the instruction
booklet I was (and still am) puzzled as to what features the watch
actually has for yachting/sailing.

So after returning home I looked on the Internet for the Citizen UK
web site but could not find one. But I did find this site:

http://www.citizendealer.com/citizen...ng_watches.htm

This stated the following details for both versions:

Citizen Model JR4010-51L / Citizen Model JR4000-55L

* Sailhawk Eco-Drive Yacht Timer Combination Quartz Watch --- The
Stars and Stripes America's Cup 2003 Official Watch. Features time and
calendar in 22 time zones, 1/100 second chronograph that measures up
to 24 hours, 99 minute countdown timer, one touch interchangeable
analog/digital times, retractable hands for display visibility, and
rotating 360 degree bezel.

* The official America's Cup insignia appears on the watch caseback
(big deal and hardly a selling point)
* Metal bracelet with all titanium case (that can be easily scratched
trying to take some links out).
* Blue dial (wow!!)
* Water resistant to 100 meters (useful)
* Safety fold over clasp with push button (useful?)
* 4 year power reserve (saves on batteries I suppose)

No other features are listed!!

So unfortunately apart from having a non-functional logo marked 'Stars
and Stripes' or 'America's Cup' I can see no extra features for
yachting that these two watches provide over and above what my very
considerably cheaper Casio basic sports timer watch already has (that
is apart from the Eco-Drive feature).

Whilst the waterproof feature is always useful for yachting, where are
the other features necessary for yachting/sailing?

I am now thinking that the watch I have is actually a simple timer and
not for yachting at all.

Specifically I'm referring to the complete lack of any navigation
functions including direction estimation, tacking angles, ability to
read in the dark (e.g. a back-lit display which my Casio has) -
important for night sailing, and wind direction and strength
estimation - to name a few.

Certainly there are absolutely NO instructions in the accompanying
booklet to describe the yachting functions (if they exist at all), not
even how to use the rotating bezel.

So please - what is the difference between the JR4000-55L and the
JR4010-51L models. Both seem to have the same features. So how do I
tell which version of the watch I have?

Also I am also having GREAT difficulty in removing some strap links to
allow me to actually wear the watch. The small arrows on some links do
not indicate any way of removing them, there are no instructions in
the booklet, and the small connecting pins are impossible to push
through using a small screwdriver. Indeed I have scratched the surface
of some of the links trying to do this. This does not say much about
the supposed hardness of the titanium band - but then I notice that
this is made in China so I suppose it is really made of soft metal and
not titanium after all.

The other SERIOUS issue I have with the watch is the button marked C
in the booklet. This is very easy to inadvertantly press with my
jacket sleeve and doing so appears to move the hour hand to indicate
the incorrect time. This is not a fault I would expect for a watch
that cost me over £200.

Frankly my year's old Casio Sports Timer cost £15 and is far better
suited to yachting and sailing. To say that I feel ripped off is an
understatement. I will NEVER purchase a Citizen watch again, and
certainly not from any duty free shop (so-called) with the word
'Colombian' in the title.

Citizen have deigned to reply to my emailed enquiries for further
information.

Fair winds and calm seas - but not for racing

C.J.Brady


Instead of berating poor Chris for being gullible enough to buy
something which he obviously didn't know anything about, we should be
thanking him for pointing out how easily it is to be misled into a
purchase - especially when it comes to anything to do with sailing -
which is usually overpriced anyway!
David C.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:23 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 BoatBanter.com