Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
![]()
posted to rec.boats.building
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Please let me know what you think about my questions in the original
post. Thanks. ----------------------- Original Post ----------------------- The core of the deck of my small center console is totally wet and rotten. I am thinking of taking this opportunity to make the whole deck removable. I mentioned the other reasons of doing this at the bottom of this message. I come across an article in continuouswaves.com where it describes a boat owner replaced the rotten wood in a removable deck with new marine plywood. I think replacing the deck with marine plywood probably is easier for me because the plywood is flat to begin with and I can glass it on a flat table. And make the deck removable will help me to do any work under the deck. And as long as the deck is open up, I can add structural bracing under the deck to support a large unsupported deck area. I am planning to cut the console from the deck and remove it. I will cut out the old deck to remove the rotten core and my "mistakes", and only leave 4" wide band of the deck near the gunwale. I will add structure to support the edge of the deck and also I will screw the deck into the added structure. I will use 3 layers of 1/4" marine plywood to form the new deck, glass it, and place it over where the old deck was, and allow its edge to butt against the gunwale, and then screw the new deck to the frame. I have some questions though: o Currently, the old deck is integrated with both the left and right gunwale in one piece. I am wondering whether the old deck may be holding the boat together to prevent the sides of the boat from spreading outward. If this is the case, I will have to leave some of the old deck in place to hold the boat together. I hope not, and I have a feeling that it doesn't. But I don't have enough experience in how a boat generally comes together. Therefore, I would like to hear what other people may say. o How many layer of fiberglass that we should put on top and on the bottom of the new deck? As mentioned above, the new deck is going to be composed of three layers of 1/4" marine plywood. If I am going to use core material, I will use 4-to-5 layers of fiberglass on top, and 1-to-2 layers on the bottom. Is this number of fiberglass also applicable in using marine plywood as core? o How do we deal with the edge of the plywood when we are laying fiberglass? Should we wrap the fiberglass around the edge from the top to the bottom? Or should we not wrap the edge and simply treat the edge with thickened epoxy? o Did anyone try this before? How did it go? Any tip? Thanks in advance for any info. Reasons of making the whole deck removable (you can skip this section if you don't want to know): o I was trying to remove the rotten core, and replace it with new core material. But I made some mistakes in mixing the epoxy, and now I need to undo the repair. Seem like cutting away the deck (the mistake) is easier than trying to scrape the epoxy from the inner skin of the deck. o The repair that I have made is kind of sagging. The reason is that I need to replace the core of a large area of the deck, and that area doesn't have anything to support it from below, and there is no access to the underside of the deck to add support to it. That's why the area became sagged when I put new core material and epoxy on it. When I look at it, I just don't like it. o The sagged area is going to be tough to fair it flat, and is going to cost me money to fill the sagged area. o This will be nice to make the deck removable; then if I need to replace the fuel tank or fuel hose, I don't need to cut the deck open again. o I need to remove two boxy structures near the stern, and cover the areas with deck. That is for adding a kicker motor later on. This means I am getting further and further away from the original deck layout anyway. I may take this opportunity to do a major makeover. o I need to move the console slightly backward to enlarge the area for the bench in front of the console in order to make room for a portable toilet (I will put it right under the bench seat). Again, I am getting further and further away from the original deck layout anyway. I may as well do a makeover of the deck. Jay Chan |
#2
![]()
posted to rec.boats.building
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Jay Chan wrote:
Please let me know what you think about my questions in the original post. Thanks. ** Jay, I'll post a few comments here; probably more later.. It's Midnight here in Africa.. A (Few?) basic questions: - How big is the boat? Length/Beam? - Outboard, right?? - Is the whole hull glass/plastic? - Is the transom sound? - I picture an open boat where you walk on the "Deck" which is low in the boat. Right? I might call that a "floor". Do I have the right picture?? Got a camera?? :-) - How does the existing deck connect to the hull? Side/Bottom? Or an inner wall section? - Does the center console sit on glassed-wood stringers or braces on the hull bottom, or was it suspended by the deck? - Um, Fresh Water or Salt? Mostly... ----------------------- Original Post ----------------------- The core of the deck of my small center console is totally wet and rotten. I am thinking of taking this opportunity to make the whole deck removable. ...snip I will use 3 layers of 1/4" marine plywood to form the new deck, glass it, and place it over where the old deck was, and allow its edge to butt against the gunwale, and then screw the new deck to the frame. ** I've built and rebuilt frames and floors, using wood, plywood, glass cloth and West Epoxy. I'm sure you can do this, with some planning.. I think you need to get the old deck pulled out before you make any decisions; you may find surprises. Hopefully no squirrels, like I did :-) Currently, the old deck is integrated with both the left and right gunwale in one piece. **?? Is the "Gunwale" an inner wall, separate from the hull side?? Hmmm.. **?? How close is the "deck" level to the outer chine level? If this is the case, I will have to leave some of the old deck in place to hold the boat together. I hope not, and I have a feeling that it doesn't. But I don't have enough experience in how a boat generally comes together. Therefore, I would like to hear what other people may say. **Hmmmm How many layer of fiberglass that we should put on top and on the bottom of the new deck? As mentioned above, the new deck is going to be composed of three layers of 1/4" marine plywood. ** Why are you using 3 layers of plywood? If you do, how will they be attached to each other? If I am going to use core material, I will use 4-to-5 layers of fiberglass on top, and 1-to-2 layers on the bottom. Is this number of fiberglass also applicable in using marine plywood as core? ** That seems like a lot of layers for a 3/4 inch thick 'deck'. You should be using some bracing strips, maybe glassed in, for stiffness of the deck... I think.. How do we deal with the edge of the plywood when we are laying fiberglass? Should we wrap the fiberglass around the edge from the top to the bottom? Or should we not wrap the edge and simply treat the edge with thickened epoxy? ** I would round over the edges about a 1/4" radius and wrap the glass top to bottom. Wet the end grain a couple of times with epoxy, let it harden, and sand before any glass. You want zero voids in the end grain or water will getcha again... Did anyone try this before? How did it go? Any tip? ** If this is the "floor" AKA "part you walk around on" in an open center console boat, yes, I've used unglassed 5/8" Plywood and glassed 1/2" plywood, with a maximum unsupported span of about 2 feet. Similar construction for the roof of my Cuddy Cabin boat, and it's "Front Deck". 2 Layers of glass/epoxy. Good bracing. Very solid feeling... Thanks in advance for any info. ** I think I would consider making the "deck" removeable for sure. But I think I'd make it in two or more sections, not one piece. If the joining lines are on a nice solid frame piece, it will be strong, with lots of stainless screws.. Aside: I did not make the floor inside my cabin removeable, originally. I recently cut it out with a sabre saw, and made a new removeable section, after I had some rot in the original just-painted 1/2" plywood. After 26 years... Hope some others will add their opinions. I have a few unorthodox materials opinions and rot-prevention opinions, but I won't cloud things yet... Jay Chan Regards, Terry King ...On The Mediterranean in Carthage |
#3
![]()
posted to rec.boats.building
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Thanks for your comments. Please see my responses highlighted with
**J** On Jan 30, 6:19 pm, " wrote: Jay Chan wrote: Please let me know what you think about my questions in the original post. Thanks. ** Jay, I'll post a few comments here; probably more later.. It's Midnight here in Africa.. A (Few?) basic questions: - How big is the boat? Length/Beam? - Outboard, right?? - Is the whole hull glass/plastic? - Is the transom sound? - I picture an open boat where you walk on the "Deck" which is low in the boat. Right? I might call that a "floor". Do I have the right picture?? Got a camera?? :-) - How does the existing deck connect to the hull? Side/Bottom? Or an inner wall section? - Does the center console sit on glassed-wood stringers or braces on the hull bottom, or was it suspended by the deck? - Um, Fresh Water or Salt? Mostly... **J** It is 18-ft with 7-ft beam, and it is a very typical center console. It has a 115hp outboard. The whole hull is fiberglass with wood structural members. The bottom of the hull is solid fiberglass. I don't know if the side of the hull is solid or cored. The deck is cored. The transom is sound. The rottened core of the deck is not directly connected to the transom (they are separated by a solid fiberglass area). Your picture of the deck being lower than the gunwale is correct. OK, I will use the term "floor" to describe the deck. I have a page of the boat in my web site he http://www.geocities.com/jaykchan/index.htm The existing floor is seamlessly connected to the side of the gunwhale, and the floor is supported by wood stringers. There are still rooms under the floor that I am considering using the space for storage. The gunwhale is hollow with spaces that I may mount fishing rods, speakers and such. I guess this probably means that the floor is not structural and is not holding the side of the hull together. The floor is not anchored permenantly on the wood stringers. They are separated. I mean the floor is simply resting on the wood stringers but not fastened to the stringers. Seem like the floor is simply being held in place by the connection to the side of the hull. I guess this also means that the floor is not structural, and I should be able to replace the floor without hurting the structure of the boat. The center console is resting directly on the wood stringers, and is not connected to the floor. I am not quite sure how the center console is being attached to the wood stringers though. The boat is a salt water boat. But it is left on a trailer. I guess this helps a bit. ----------------------- Original Post ----------------------- The core of the deck of my small center console is totally wet and rotten. I am thinking of taking this opportunity to make the whole deck removable. ..snip I will use 3 layers of 1/4" marine plywood to form the new deck, glass it, and place it over where the old deck was, and allow its edge to butt against the gunwale, and then screw the new deck to the frame. ** I've built and rebuilt frames and floors, using wood, plywood, glass cloth and West Epoxy. I'm sure you can do this, with some planning.. I think you need to get the old deck pulled out before you make any decisions; you may find surprises. Hopefully no squirrels, like I did :-) **J** I will definitely make the final decision after I have cut the old floor out. I don't think there will be any squirrel in the boat because I have several nice/warm compost piles in my backyard that I think will be more appealing than the cold/hard fiberglass boat; moreover, I have a chimney that the squirrels also may find very appealing (one did). Currently, the old deck is integrated with both the left and right gunwale in one piece. **?? Is the "Gunwale" an inner wall, separate from the hull side?? Hmmm.. **J** The gunwale is hollow. The inner side of the gunwale connects to the floor, and the outer side connecting to the side of the hull. I have a feeling that the hull is made in one piece from one mold, and the gunwale/floor combo is made in one piece from another mold. And then they are attached together like this (please use fixed-spacing font like Courier to view the line art): Gunwale/floor combo: /----\ /----\ | | | | | | | | |----------------------------| | | Attached to V Hull: | | | | \ / \ / \ / \--------\ /--------/ \ / \--------/ **?? How close is the "deck" level to the outer chine level? **J** I figure the floor is probably 4 to 5 inches above the chine level. If this is the case, I will have to leave some of the old deck in place to hold the boat together. I hope not, and I have a feeling that it doesn't. But I don't have enough experience in how a boat generally comes together. Therefore, I would like to hear what other people may say. **Hmmmm How many layer of fiberglass that we should put on top and on the bottom of the new deck? As mentioned above, the new deck is going to be composed of three layers of 1/4" marine plywood. ** Why are you using 3 layers of plywood? If you do, how will they be attached to each other? **J** I get that idea by reading the guy in www.continuouswave.com who replaced his rotten deck with 3 layers of 1/4" plywood all glued together using thickened epoxy. His idea of using 3 thin layers instead of 2 thicker layers is to be able to stack the joint. I guess if I can find one large piece of marine plywood, I will be able to use one thick layer instead of 3 thin layers. But I have a feeling that I may have a problem locating one large piece of marine plywood. The mail order houses seem to only ship in small pieces. I guess this is about time for me to look for a mail order house that can ship one large piece of plywood. If I am going to use core material, I will use 4-to-5 layers of fiberglass on top, and 1-to-2 layers on the bottom. Is this number of fiberglass also applicable in using marine plywood as core? ** That seems like a lot of layers for a 3/4 inch thick 'deck'. You should be using some bracing strips, maybe glassed in, for stiffness of the deck... I think.. **J** Your idea of using bracing strips is good. Actually the rear deck area of the boat is totally under-braced and I should add additional bracing in there anyway. Let me ask you a quesion: Let say we have added additional bracing to make sure the bracing strips are not more than 2-ft apart, and we use 3/4" marine plywood (in one piece or in 3 thin layers combined). How many layers of fiberglass would you recommend? I know that you will recommend using 2 layers of fiberglass if I use 1/2" marine plywood instead of 3/4" because you have mentioned this below. How do we deal with the edge of the plywood when we are laying fiberglass? Should we wrap the fiberglass around the edge from the top to the bottom? Or should we not wrap the edge and simply treat the edge with thickened epoxy? ** I would round over the edges about a 1/4" radius and wrap the glass top to bottom. Wet the end grain a couple of times with epoxy, let it harden, and sand before any glass. You want zero voids in the end grain or water will getcha again... **J** Thanks for the good tip. I will follow this when I get to that point. Did anyone try this before? How did it go? Any tip? ** If this is the "floor" AKA "part you walk around on" in an open center console boat, yes, I've used unglassed 5/8" Plywood and glassed 1/2" plywood, with a maximum unsupported span of about 2 feet. Similar construction for the roof of my Cuddy Cabin boat, and it's "Front Deck". 2 Layers of glass/epoxy. Good bracing. Very solid feeling... **J** Great to know this! This means 1/2" or 5/8" plywood is a viable alternative to 3/4" thick plywood. Good, less thick means lower weight. And I will use 2 layers of fiberglass/epoxy -- may be 3 (just to be in the safe side)... Thanks in advance for any info. ** I think I would consider making the "deck" removeable for sure. But I think I'd make it in two or more sections, not one piece. If the joining lines are on a nice solid frame piece, it will be strong, with lots of stainless screws.. **J** I have the same feeling too. I will be making the floor in multiple small sections instead of one giant piece. A small piece is easier to handle than a giant piece anyway. Aside: I did not make the floor inside my cabin removeable, originally. I recently cut it out with a sabre saw, and made a new removeable section, after I had some rot in the original just-painted 1/2" plywood. After 26 years... Hope some others will add their opinions. I have a few unorthodox materials opinions and rot-prevention opinions, but I won't cloud things yet... Jay Chan Regards, Terry King ...On The Mediterranean in Carthage **J** Enjoy your stay in Mediterranean, and I look forward to hear your advice -- orthodox or unorthodox. Jay Chan |
#5
![]()
posted to rec.boats.building
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Please see my response in ****J****
On Feb 1, 4:46 am, " wrote: On Jan 31, 7:51 pm, "Jay Chan" wrote: ..snip It is 18-ft with 7-ft beam, and it is a very typical center console. It has a 115hp outboard. The whole hull is fiberglass with wood structural members. The bottom of the hull is solid fiberglass. I have a page of the boat in my web site hehttp://www.geocities.com/jaykchan/index.htm **T* Jay, could you email me a photo at ?? Sigh.. - You are on GeoCities - One or more of the 1000's on Geocity said something about the president of the Country I am in. - Geocities.com is "Impossible de trouver la page" in this country ****J**** I didn't know that having a web site in geosities.com this can be a problem to you. OK, I will email some pictures to you when I get back home. The existing floor is seamlessly connected to the side of the gunwhale, and the floor is supported by wood stringers. The floor is not anchored permanently on the wood stringers. The center console is resting directly on the wood stringers, and is not connected to the floor. I am not quite sure how the center console is being attached to the wood stringers though. ... **J** The gunwale is hollow. The inner side of the gunwale connects to the floor, and the outer side connecting to the side of the hull. I have a feeling that the hull is made in one piece from one mold, and the gunwale/floor combo is made in one piece from another mold. And then they are attached together like this (please use fixed-spacing font like Courier to view the line art): Gunwale/floor combo: /----\ /----\ | | | | | | | | |----------------------------| | | Attached to V Hull: | | | | \ / \ / \ / \--------\ /--------/ \ / \--------/ **T* OK, that's what I thought. Yes, this boat is made by making the hull in one mold, adding some wood/glass supports to the hull, and making the top/gunwhale/inside-sides/floor in another mold, and mating the two pieces together. ****J**** Thanks for the confirmation. This means the floor is not structural, and I should not have a structural problem when I remove the floor. ** Why are you using 3 layers of plywood? If you do, how will they be attached to each other? **J** I get that idea by reading the guy inwww.continuouswave.comwho replaced his rotten deck with 3 layers of 1/4" plywood all glued together using thickened epoxy. His idea of using 3 thin layers instead of 2 thicker layers is to be able to stack the joint. I guess if I can find one large piece of marine plywood, I will be able to use one thick layer instead of 3 thin layers. But I have a feeling that I may have a problem locating one large piece of marine plywood. The mail order houses seem to only ship in small pieces. I guess this is about time for me to look for a mail order house that can ship one large piece of plywood. ,,snip.. **T* OK, that's a method of making 'long' plywood.. But, since you don't NEED long plywood, and the 'floor' is not hull-structural, there are other possibilities.. ****J**** I see. This means I may be able to use one layer of marine plywood instead of glueing three layers together -- that is as long as I can find the piece that is wide enough to cover the width of the boat (I try to avoid having too many screws right in the middle of the floor, and I prefer the screws to be near the edge of the floor). This should reduce my time in preparing the floor replacement. Thanks! **T* Blasphemous-according-to-some idea: I have used higher-grade Pressure-Treated plywood for some boat sections. I scrubbed it down hard with detergent, dried it inside, then supported it in the sun for a few days before (carefully with mask) cutting / epoxying it. The off-boat samples I did seem to have fine adhesion.. If I had to replace that floor right now, I'd use pressure-treated 1/2 - 5/8 or 3/4 plywood (depending on the span and springiness you can accept.). Adding 3 layers of glass on top (to survive another 20 years of foot traffic) and one or two on the bottom will make it a lot stiffer. I bet 1/2" with all that glass would be fine. Consider using a colorant in the last 2 top layers, and never paint it! ****J**** I will hesistate to use pressure treated plywood. The pressure treated plywoods available in home centers around here look really bad -- all warped and full of voids and really wet. I think I will pay the extra and order marine plywood. The pressure treated solid woods in home center look more promising, and I may use them as stringers _if_ somehow I can get them to dry in time for the repair, and this can be a problem. I will paint the glassed surface because I need to put on a non-skid surface on the floor. And I need to make sure that I have a layer of finish on the epoxy surface to prevent water from getting through the epoxy layer. Major part of the work is to assess and repair and add the floor stringers so that the floor both has adequate support AND has good places for the floor joints. Since the floor is not structural and will not have any tension loading you don't need much in the way of attachment except you don't want it moving / vibrating underway. Stainless steel screws are OK as long as you do NOT paint them in place or bury them in glass. Turns out Stainless needs Oxygen to keep it's corrosion resistance! I'd use countersunk (epoxy over the raw edge) holes and those square-drive BeaverBite screws, myself. Then the floor sections are removeable. I'd want to remove them every year or two to clean everything and check the stringers etc. AND the stringers! Better get a good look at them and see if any have gotten wet or got any rot. Look at: Epoxy Knowhow and Chemotherapy for Rot at:http://www.angelfire.com/nc3/davecarnell/ (Hopefully your local government hasn't Fired the Angels) Second Point of Blasphemy: I have a few wood areas in my current boat (28 years) that have some rot, but are pretty sound still, and are mostly encapsulated in Glass. Now they have several 1/4" holes it the topmost point and get a yearly dose of DaveC. Stable, no changes, no evidence of any biological activity, after 5 to 8 years of this. And a LOT less toxic than the PentaChlor I used to get at the Marina. Yup, PCP! No longer available.. The "Penetrating Epoxy" I used earlier on rot worked. Until it rotted all AROUND it! :-( I think you can handle this well, once you get into it... I agree you should pull the console, mainly to get a look at its stringers. ****J**** Thanks for reminding me to check the stringers. This makes perfect sense to check them while I have the floor cut open. I will focus on the stringers under the area where the T-top anchored on the floor and where the water went through and rotted the core. Thanks for pointing out that I should not paint over stainless steel screws. I didn't know that, and I was thinking of painting over them. What you said also explains the reason why people need to remove stainless steel staplers after using them to fix something in place temporarily -- I was wondering about why not just epoxy the staplers over. Your idea of using bracing strips is good. Actually the rear deck area of the boat is totally under-braced and I should add additional bracing in there anyway. Let me ask you a quesion: Let say we have added additional bracing to make sure the bracing strips are not more than 2-ft apart, and we use 3/4" marine plywood (in one piece or in 3 thin layers combined). **T* Stringers: Mahogany is great stuff, but getting hard to find and expensive. I used Cedar Flooring on edge for some floor stringers and cabin roof stringers. And the epoxy-on-cedar looks real nice in the cabin... ****J**** Sorry to hear that mahogany is in short supply. I guess I will just have to get whatever marine wood is available and don't worry about if they are mahogany or not. Or I will stock up on pressure treated solid woods and wait for them to dry (probably not). How many layers of fiberglass would you recommend? I know that you will recommend using 2 layers of fiberglass if I use 1/2" marine plywood instead of 3/4" because you have mentioned this below. **T* Sounds good. You COULD test a floor section after N layers of glass to see how stiff it was... ..snip **J** Great to know this! This means 1/2" or 5/8" plywood is a viable alternative to 3/4" thick plywood. Good, less thick means lower weight. And I will use 2 layers of fiberglass/epoxy -- may be 3 (just to be in the safe side)... ** I think I would consider making the "deck" removeable for sure. **J** I have the same feeling too. I will be making the floor in multiple small sections instead of one giant piece. A small piece is easier to handle than a giant piece anyway. **T* Hope someone else will comment; I know some of you guys have done a lot; I have only done what I've done, on 2 boats.... Terry Yours is two boats more experience than mine. Glad to learn from you. Jay Chan |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Epoxy or Polyester for Fixing Rotten Core on Deck? | Boat Building | |||
rec.boats.paddle sea kayaking FAQ | General | |||
rec.boats.paddle sea kayaking FAQ | General | |||
HOW TO TURN $6 TO $6000 | Boat Building | |||
Just How Safe Do You Feel? | General |