Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Full Batten or not?
Hello,
I'm about to buy a brand new main sail for my C&C 27. I'm debating between full batten or not (Dacron). I use the boat primarily for cruising. Are full batten sails easy to reef? Would a full batten sail give me extra speed? I don't race this boat but I race others, so I like to have my sails tune-up for maximum speed always. I'm looking at UK sails since that is what I have in the boat and it worked very well for many years, but I'm open to other suggestions as well. Any help/suggestions will be greatly appreciated. Thanks, Guillermo |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Full Batten or not?
I think full battens are great. Easy to reef, less flogging, etc. I have has
them on a Freedom 28 and a Saga 35. I also have dutchman system on the main which is really nice, and strongly recommend it. My boat is 35 feet, so the Dutchman may be overkill for a 27. "Guillermo" wrote in message ... Hello, I'm about to buy a brand new main sail for my C&C 27. I'm debating between full batten or not (Dacron). I use the boat primarily for cruising. Are full batten sails easy to reef? Would a full batten sail give me extra speed? I don't race this boat but I race others, so I like to have my sails tune-up for maximum speed always. I'm looking at UK sails since that is what I have in the boat and it worked very well for many years, but I'm open to other suggestions as well. Any help/suggestions will be greatly appreciated. Thanks, Guillermo |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Full Batten or not?
Full battens come in really handy if your sailing in relatively light air,
as they help hold the sail shape better. I believe that they were designed more for sailing off the wind to gain that extra little bit of sail area for the wind to push on. Going upwind, they will increase healing as they present more sail area to the wind higher up. Full Batten sails typically have larger roaches. This is something else to consider. I have full battens on my C&C 30, the main's pretty blown out, but I still get good speed out of it. The only pain is that the roach catches the backstay just a bit on tacks (causing chafe) and in light air you can end up with an inverted main because the battens didn't flip. This can be reduced by having less batten tension, but I don't think you can ever eliminate it. A quick flip of the main will ensure everything pops into place. I don't really notice any difference in reefing full batten main vs a "partial" batten main. I've got two reef points and have used both of them. If I was planning to buy a new main, I'd probably go with a loose footed full batten main because the winds go light in the summer (typically) and I need every inch of cloth I can get. My new main would be about 1/2 inch less on the roach so it wouldn't tear itself apart on the backstay, but that's about it. Don Casey wrote a few words about this in "This Old Boat", and I'm sure you could find a few sailmakers comments around. Have you tried discussing with the sailmaker on what he would recommend and WHY. Just did a goole search on full batten main and some guy had posted to a news group indicating that it's too hard to tell what the sail is doing in light airs. I don't see this as a big problem, so long as you have a few well placed telltales. Well, that's my 2 cents worth and probably a bit more. -- Cheers, Jeffrey Nelson Muir Caileag C&C 30 "Guillermo" wrote in message ... Hello, I'm about to buy a brand new main sail for my C&C 27. I'm debating between full batten or not (Dacron). I use the boat primarily for cruising. Are full batten sails easy to reef? Would a full batten sail give me extra speed? I don't race this boat but I race others, so I like to have my sails tune-up for maximum speed always. I'm looking at UK sails since that is what I have in the boat and it worked very well for many years, but I'm open to other suggestions as well. Any help/suggestions will be greatly appreciated. Thanks, Guillermo |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Full Batten or not?
I have a lightly used set of laminated sails about 3 years old for my C&C
27-5 that I'm not planning to use. I had recently thought about selling them. Thanks, but I'm not looking to race in this boat. Cruising sails is what I'm after, so Dacron would be my choice. Guillermo |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Full Batten or not?
sailmakers comments around. Have you tried discussing with the sailmaker on what he would recommend and WHY. Yes I did, however full batten sails are more expensive and therefore sailmakers will be more incline to sale those. They think full batten is the way to go, but I wanted to know what other users have experienced. I have also posted my question into a C&C 27 forum and it turns out that everybody likes full batten sails. It looks like full batten is the way to go these days. Thank you all for you input in this matter. Guillermo |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Full Batten or not?
It is the way to go, Guillermo! They(full batten) are faster, they are
better/easier to trim and they last longer! With the right setup they will also reef quicker and won't balloon away from you, because they are stiffer. All plus points. And.....when you sail you might as well sail fast.......or faster than your buddies ;-) Even when cruising to cut 3/4 - 1hour of a 5-6 hour journey is considerable and not difficult to take. Especially when there are children o/b or bad weather. Happy sailing, you will not regret it. -- c ya Wim www.cruising.ca/thousand/f-index.html "Guillermo" wrote in message ... : : sailmakers comments around. Have you tried discussing with the sailmaker : on : what he would : recommend and WHY. : : Yes I did, however full batten sails are more expensive and therefore : sailmakers will be more incline to sale those. They think full batten is : the way to go, but I wanted to know what other users have experienced. : : I have also posted my question into a C&C 27 forum and it turns out that : everybody likes full batten sails. : : It looks like full batten is the way to go these days. : : Thank you all for you input in this matter. : Guillermo : : |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Full Batten or not?
i have a new NS main on a 29ft'r and only the two upper battons are full
(come to the leach). It doesn't flog and doesn't need expensive bat cars. the other rick On Wed, 26 Nov 2003 15:22:41 -0500, Rick (Saga 35) wrote: I think full battens are great. Easy to reef, less flogging, etc. I have has them on a Freedom 28 and a Saga 35. I also have dutchman system on the main which is really nice, and strongly recommend it. My boat is 35 feet, so the Dutchman may be overkill for a 27. "Guillermo" wrote in message ... Hello, I'm about to buy a brand new main sail for my C&C 27. I'm debating snip... |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Full Batten or not?
I agree that full battens are the best choice, but there is one drawback
which though implied, hasn't been mentioned explicitly. With full battens and conventional slides, it is nearly impossible to get the sail down unless heading directly upwind. This is not a serious drawback for most people, but you should be aware of it. Steve C&C 27 "Wim" wrote in message ... It is the way to go, Guillermo! They(full batten) are faster, they are better/easier to trim and they last longer! With the right setup they will also reef quicker and won't balloon away from you, because they are stiffer. All plus points. And.....when you sail you might as well sail fast.......or faster than your buddies ;-) Even when cruising to cut 3/4 - 1hour of a 5-6 hour journey is considerable and not difficult to take. Especially when there are children o/b or bad weather. Happy sailing, you will not regret it. -- c ya Wim www.cruising.ca/thousand/f-index.html "Guillermo" wrote in message ... : : sailmakers comments around. Have you tried discussing with the sailmaker : on : what he would : recommend and WHY. : : Yes I did, however full batten sails are more expensive and therefore : sailmakers will be more incline to sale those. They think full batten is : the way to go, but I wanted to know what other users have experienced. : : I have also posted my question into a C&C 27 forum and it turns out that : everybody likes full batten sails. : : It looks like full batten is the way to go these days. : : Thank you all for you input in this matter. : Guillermo : : |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Full Batten or not?
I have full battens, and the sail drops effortlessly. I have the low
friction nylon track with the low-friction batten cars. Really works! I am a strong advocate of full battens - I think they are great. -- ================= Rick Krementz Saga 35 - Nastianna Jersey City NJ email address available at www.krementz.com ==================== "Steve Thomas" wrote in message . .. I agree that full battens are the best choice, but there is one drawback which though implied, hasn't been mentioned explicitly. With full battens and conventional slides, it is nearly impossible to get the sail down unless heading directly upwind. This is not a serious drawback for most people, but you should be aware of it. Steve C&C 27 "Wim" wrote in message ... It is the way to go, Guillermo! They(full batten) are faster, they are better/easier to trim and they last longer! With the right setup they will also reef quicker and won't balloon away from you, because they are stiffer. All plus points. And.....when you sail you might as well sail fast.......or faster than your buddies ;-) Even when cruising to cut 3/4 - 1hour of a 5-6 hour journey is considerable and not difficult to take. Especially when there are children o/b or bad weather. Happy sailing, you will not regret it. -- c ya Wim www.cruising.ca/thousand/f-index.html "Guillermo" wrote in message ... : : sailmakers comments around. Have you tried discussing with the sailmaker : on : what he would : recommend and WHY. : : Yes I did, however full batten sails are more expensive and therefore : sailmakers will be more incline to sale those. They think full batten is : the way to go, but I wanted to know what other users have experienced. : : I have also posted my question into a C&C 27 forum and it turns out that : everybody likes full batten sails. : : It looks like full batten is the way to go these days. : : Thank you all for you input in this matter. : Guillermo : : |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Full Batten or not?
What are the main dimensions of your sails?
I have a C&C 27 MK III (1978) which I realize is a different boat, but I don't know if your sails would be much different or not. I don't know much about the later model 27s. I do know that new high-tech sails are more than I want to spend just now. Steve Thomas.. wrote in message news On Wed, 26 Nov 2003 11:21:16 -0800, "Guillermo" wrote: Hello, I'm about to buy a brand new main sail for my C&C 27. I'm debating between full batten or not (Dacron). I use the boat primarily for cruising. Are full batten sails easy to reef? Would a full batten sail give me extra speed? I don't race this boat but I race others, so I like to have my sails tune-up for maximum speed always. I'm looking at UK sails since that is what I have in the boat and it worked very well for many years, but I'm open to other suggestions as well. Any help/suggestions will be greatly appreciated. Thanks, Guillermo What version of the C&C 27? Where are you located near? I have a lightly used set of laminated sails about 3 years old for my C&C 27-5 that I'm not planning to use. I had recently thought about selling them. They are a great set, made by Elliot Paterson. The Main has almost no use on it at all, and the jib was used for one season of Wednesday night races.. They are Kevlar w/mylar film and they were made w/Bainbridge sail cloth (some of the best on the market even now). The full batten Main is a little bigger than my cruising Dacron and the Jib is right around a 155% (about as big as you can go in PHRF racing without taking a hit on your rating). BB |
Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Help - Perkins 20hp diesel yacht motor wont achieve full revs under load | Cruising | |||
Habbi's gearcase full of water | General | |||
Gearcase full of water | General | |||
For Sale : full size Dagger FreeFall in California Bay Area | Whitewater | |||
Full duplex VHF or FRS??? | Electronics |